The RED-BACKED SHRIKE Twitch To Powell River!

On Friday my friend Iwan Van Veen sent me a photo of a blurry Asian shrike. I could tell right away it was an Asian shrike and I thought due to range most likely it would be Brown.

He had first thought on Thursday when he first saw the bird that it was a Northern Shrike but something bugged him about the bird so he went back and got the photo. Once he saw it more clear he figured he probably had a Brown Shrike too.

Well because the photo was blurry I said we can’t rule out the other Asian shrikes like Red-backed, Isabelline and Red-tailed and could you go back and get better photos. Well he did that same day. He got every angle of the bird covered which would be needed for expert opinions.

I studied up reading this amazing article by Dutch Birding and after consulting with a few others thought "oh my gosh this looks better for Red-backed"as so many features were lining up!. Since I had never seen Red-backed Shrike and it would be the first record for Canada and the second for the ABA I quickly began consulting experts. Lehman sent me the excellent paper he wrote about his first record for North American Birds as well and Pyle sent me his detailed paper on the California hybrid Red-tailed X Red-backed.

I got expert opinions from Korea in Asia,  Europe (Sweden etc) and Israel and experts in America. 
All of them came back with this is a 1st year male Red-backed Shrike. Truly incredible. They also said there was no visible signs of hybridism and no inconsistencies in that regard. Big thank you especially to Nial Moores, Lars Svensson, Julian Hough, Jonathan Meyrav, Yoav Perlman, Peter Pyle, Paul Lehman, Itai Shanni and the detailed phone conversation with my friend Michael Force.

What a phenomenal record and find for my friend Iwan and what a blessing that it stuck around for so many to see it. Ilya and I had packed up the same night and arrived at Powell River at midnight. We didn’t get much sleep that night because we were so nervous the bird wouldn’t be there. The skies were clear and we heard Snow Geese migrating over our heads all night lol! Well the next morning was Ilya’s birthday and we went there and saw friendly familiar faces from Vancouver, Vancouver Island and the Sunshine Coast and 1 from Ontario and the star himself Iwan. Many of my friends from WA texted me how much they wanted to be there too but couldn't of course due to the border closure.

I don’t think he’s ever seen this many birders in Powell River. The last time I was there for the Black-tailed Gull the numbers didn’t even compare. A nice news article about Iwan’s find was published that you can read HERE. 

Anyways after a very freezing cold morning the bird showed up at 8:30am hunting from a vacant lot. Everyone was thrilled we could even count the diagnostic 7 primaries extending past the tertials. We could clearly see the rufous brown ear spot and the white flanks and underbelly lacking any buff wash. The back was heavily scalloped and the weak facial supercilium evident. The bright red tail with outer rect with prominent white edging with black subterminal mark all were diagnostic of this species.  

All field marks were clear. How exciting and what a thrill and a great birthday present for Ilya. He’s seen them before in Ukraine but his BC list to him is more important than his life list. I’m the other way, where my life list is more important than my BC list, so we were both happy. It was BC Bird # 439 for me and ABA bird #718!. We watched him hunt and successfully catch a cricket, beetle and eat a berry. He also had blood on his beak so probably got a mouse.

1st year male Red-backed Shrike in Powell River - Photo: Melissa Hafting

After a nice Thai lunch we birded Cranberry Lake after and then scoped the ocean and saw a massive raft of Sea Lions. We then went home via Saltery Bay ferry and at Earl’s Cove we’re delighted to see a small herd of coastal Elk with a nice Bull.

Elk in Egmont, BC - Photo: Melissa Hafting

The next day I got up and saw a Harris’s Sparrow (Canada's only endemic breeder and NA's biggest sparrow) and vagrant Blue Jay to cap off my weekend. They were birds 260 and 261 respectively. I wonder if 270 is possible again this year? Time will tell. It is now evident that 250 is not much of a challenge anymore the way information is changed and the new goal should be 260 in my opinion as well as Keith Riding who told me the same last year.

Harris's Sparrow in Richmond - Photo: Melissa Hafting

Blue Jay in Richmond - Photos: Melissa Hafting

What a great weekend with a truly incredible bird that brightened up the lives of many birders in this dreary pandemic!.

Comments

  1. LonelytravellerOctober 26, 2020 at 7:29 PM

    Congratulations on seeing such a rare bird. Some beautiful pictures as well

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Melissa HaftingOctober 27, 2020 at 4:46 PM

      thank you so much! i was thrilled he got so close at one point after hours of waiting in the freezing cold!

      Delete
  2. Shou Ye GauthierOctober 26, 2020 at 9:37 PM

    Wow this is so excellent Mel. Congratulations

    ReplyDelete
  3. Jim CumminsOctober 27, 2020 at 6:11 AM

    Awesome twitch. I'm happy for you. Great shots. I should make hour drive and see if I can find the Blue Jay that isn't far from me.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Melissa HaftingOctober 27, 2020 at 4:45 PM

      thanks so much jim. i hope you get out to see that blue jay!

      Delete
  4. RedwingOctober 27, 2020 at 8:29 AM

    Melissa, congratulatons to you and Ilya.

    ReplyDelete
  5. LironOctober 27, 2020 at 8:36 AM

    What an amazing bird and incredible twitch!! Congrats!! Great shots too.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Melissa HaftingOctober 27, 2020 at 4:45 PM

      thanks liron it sure was one of the coolest birds ive ever seen in bc thanks again :)

      Delete
  6. MikeOctober 28, 2020 at 9:47 AM

    OH my mel this is fabulous! your photos are the best by far i've seen of the BC Red-backed shrike!

    ReplyDelete
  7. KenOctober 28, 2020 at 12:19 PM

    Mel
    Fabulous twitch and such an incredible bird. Your photos are ( as usual) absolutely outstanding. Now, I m just hoping it hangs around until Fri., then I can pop over from Comox
    Ken

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Melissa HaftingOctober 28, 2020 at 9:43 PM

      thank you so much ken that It is so very kind! I am crossing my fingers and toes for you that the bird sticks till friday :D!!

      Delete
  8. NorskNovember 4, 2020 at 9:08 PM

    great photos of an incredible bird melissa. glad you got to see it! this was a fun and interesting read. congratulations to iwan on his impressive find!

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular Posts

Dowitcher Identification

Image
Birders notoriously find it difficult to tell Short-billed and Long-billed Dowitchers apart. I have got a request to do an identification explanation on them so here goes, I hope it will be helpful. Short-billed Dowitchers and Long-billed look so similar. Using their habitat is helpful but not diagnostic. Short-billed Dowitchers tend to prefer Salt water and brackish water and Long-billed Dowitchers tend to prefer fresh water. However, I have OFTEN seen Short-billeds in freshwater and Long-billeds in brackish and salt water. Therefore, DO NOT rely on habitat. Another feature many people will tell you to rely on is spotting on the side of the flanks of Short-billeds and barring on the side of Long-billeds. Usually this is a mark that you can use but it is not always as distinct as you like. I have seen Short-billeds with a barred appearance to the flanks. It is only at the side of the breast where you have to look for this diagnostic feature for the spots on a Short-billed and t
Read more

Hawk Identification Tips from every angle (Sharpie vs Cooper and Red-tailed Subspecies)

Image
I get several questions about the difference between accipiters. The most common ones are between Sharp-shinned Hawks and Cooper's Hawks and between Cooper's Hawks vs Northern Goshawks (to a lesser degree). Next, I get many questions dealing with a certain race of buteos the Western Red-tailed Hawk and Harlan's. So I thought I would do a post on these to help answer those questions. I will deal with Cooper's and Sharpies and not Goshawks because they are much more common here and look much more alike. My friend John Reynolds inspired me to write this up. COOPER'S AND SHARP-SHINNED HAWKS EYE COLOUR - YELLOW OR ORANGE? RED? Normally a juvenile Cooper's hawk has a bright yellow eye and a Juvie Sharpie has a orange eye but some cooper's can have a dull yellow eye that looks a bit orangish. Cooper's Hawks usually only transition to the orange eye colour when they are sub adults, so in good light, it's a very very reliable feature. However you
Read more

STINT IDENTIFICATION

Image
As per request, here are some tips that I hope will be helpful in identifying and differentiating Red-necked Stint from Little Stint. I will also do a brief intro on Long-toed and Temminck's Stint... if you build it they will come right?😉 Red-necked and Little Stints look very much alike in worn breeding plumage. The amount of Red on the face, throat and breast in Red-necked Stint is vary variable). They look even more alike in non-breeding plumage, that is why it is essential to learn structural differences to separate the two. They are similar to Semipalmated Sandpipers as well as Sanderlings. Both species are often confused for Red-necked Stints. Little Stints rarely get confused with Sanderling because they have a hind toe which helps differentiate it from this species. Sanderlings in breeding or worn breeding are usually confused with Red-necked Stints but they are much larger than Red-necked Stints. Let's first start with Bills in this complicated ID proces
Read more

*Updated - The most famous Red-tailed Hawk is eating fish on the ground just like a Bald Eagle!

Image
Update - There are plans in the works to make a documentary film on this young Red-tailed Hawk who thinks he's an Eagle. You can read the latest news about that on CBC HERE . Watch this incredible footage of the little Red-tailed Hawk who grew up in a family of three Eaglets and 2 Bald Eagle Parents. He is imprinted now on Bald Eagles. He looks and acts just like one, as you can see here in the video below. He is standing over a large salmon carcass, just like a Bald Eagle would and he's eating the decaying flesh. Red-tailed Hawks like to eat voles and rabbits etc. not fish! Imprinting is usually irreversible according to raptor expert David Bird. However, I hope it's reversible so that he doesn't attempt to mate with a Bald Eagle, as the Eagle would kill him because it would view him as a Hawk. Eagle expert David Hancock said that the bird will likely starve and get killed by an eagle. He said this possibly can be prevented if someone grabs it and takes it to O
Read more

My First Mother's Day Without My Mother

Image
This is my first Mother’s Day without my mom. I am still deeply affected and afflicted with emotional pain. I took the day off from the RBA to just remember her and honour her. My dad, sister and I visited her grave with a bouquet of flowers. I cried a lot but it gives me a bit of comfort that she now has a head stone that I can touch. I didn't want to leave. I can’t believe it’s been just over 4 months since I lost her. To my Mom: Mom you were so great. You were so loved. I miss you so much today. I wish every day that you were here with Meghan, Dad and I.  I will never be truly happy again until I see you once more. Thank you for being such a wonderful mother. I will never ever forget you. I cannot wait to see you again in Heaven. Since you died in my arms, this is one of the hardest days I have been through without you. Normally I would be taking you out for brunch today, hugging you and telling you how much I loved you. Mom, you watched me take my first breath and I unfortunate
Read more